This brings me back to fear. The last time the Left had this much pull was during the Great Depression. There are parallels between that time and ours. In some ways the Depression was worse than anything we know now. But in at lest in one way, it seems like things are far worse today.
C.R. Wiley over at Paterfamilias makes some superb points about why socialism is so appealing to young people. Check out the article, it is short, so have a read.
I have two responses.
First, to the quote above. The implication that the left has a lot of pull is hard to square with the fellow in the White House and the GOP-dominated Senate. That didn’t just happen: it is an illustration that, for whatever pull the left has, it is pushing at least as many people away. (Plus, I’d argue that the left had more pull between 1966-1974 than it does now. Disagree? Explain why Nixon was arguably the most liberal Republican president of the past half-century.)
Second, and somewhat associated with the first, is that fear does not drive people left, it drives people to political extremes, the fringes of the political plain. Fear tends to empty the center, stoking radicals, reactionaries, libertarians, and anarchists at the expense of the moderates.
And that’s our problem. We have become a nation of fear, screaming at each other from the fringes at the expense of the democratic process.
Becoming a socialist (or a radical libertarian, or anarcho-syndicalyst, or a monarchist, or a fascist) is not going to fix that: it is going to exacerbate the problem. Figuring out how to work with people who hate your guts, and doing so for the betterment of both of you, is what is going to fix our real problems.